Scenario-Based Verification

Purpose of Scenario-Based Vehicle Simulation

Scenario-based verification in simulation is a technique used to create, test and analyze hypothetical operating situations in a controlled environment. This method is utilized for various purposes, including testing vehicle performance, improving vehicle safety, and developing autonomous vehicle technologies.

Scenario-based vehicle simulation is employed to test and evaluate vehicle systems and driver responses in a variety of operating conditions. Scenario-based testing serves several critical purposes across different domains, each aimed at enhancing safety, performance, and innovation in vehicle-related fields by exploring a wide range of scenarios (operating environment & traffic/entity interactions).

Scenario Variations – Permutations

In order to test “a variety of operating conditions”, a scenario’s parameters are modified to create variations. A “variation” of a scenario can be called permutation. If a scenario has 2 parameters with 2 values each, we would get up to 2×2=4 permutations of the scenario. Simplified example:
Initial Vehicle Speed = [30, 40]m/s
Vehicle Weight = [1000, 1100]kg.
Please see further below for more examples of parameters.

As the number of parameters and varying values of those parameters increase, the number of possible permutations will explode and be represented by a multi-dimensional parameter matrix. It is common that there are too many possible permutations, introducing the need to do one of the following:

• Specify necessary subset of permutations beforehand.
• Exploratively run interesting permutations “on-the-fly”, each run scenario’s simulation results would be analyzed and used to determine what permutation to run next to achieve goals such as:
  – Find parameters resulting in failure of test cases.
  – Find parameters resulting in optimal values for defined KPI (Key Performance Indicators).

Components of Scenario-Based Vehicle Simulation

Scenarios are crafted to reflect specific operating conditions of vehicles and surrounding environment, e.g. roads, weather conditions & vehicle actions. The following scenario components:
Scenario Environment, Vehicle Control – Predefined
can be:

• Based on real-world data to ensure they are realistic and relevant.
• Based on design requirements & safety standards.
• Generated, beforehand or “on-the-fly”.

Scenario Environment

The environment the simulated vehicles move around in.

Parameter examples:
– Road length
– Wind velocity

Vehicle Control – Predefined

Predefined vehicle operation instructions. This includes other vehicles in the simulation as well (e.g. traffic).
Instructions can be time-based, or conditional.

Parameter examples:
– Initial ego vehicle speed
– Accelerate as much as possible for first 10 seconds.

Vehicle Control – Adaptive

All control of the vehicle that is not predefined before simulation we can say is adapted “live” as simulation goes on.
If the simulation contains any adaptive control, the simulation is closed-loop (What is closed & open loop simulation?).
We have two types of adaptive control: Control Logic & Operator Simulator.

Control Logic
This includes all automatic control of vehicles, e.g. automatic braking feature.

Parameter examples:
– PID controller values

Operator Simulator
This can for example be a simulated driver/pilot.

Parameter examples:
– Reaction speed

Simulation Models & Vehicle Characteristics

Computational models represents components such as vehicle dynamics, sensor systems, and the environment. These models simulate how the vehicle behaves under different conditions, including acceleration, braking, steering, and interactions with other vehicles and entities. Vehicle characteristics can be parameterized.

Parameter examples:
– Vehicle weight
– Simulated sensor/radar/lidar noise parameters.

Execution, Feedback and Analysis

The simulation either provides real-time or post-processed analysis feedback.
After simulation, analysis is conducted to understand the impact of different variables, such as operator behavior, vehicle response, and environmental conditions. It is common apply automatic test cases to a scenario’s test results, giving verdict on product maturity.

Parameter examples:
– Simulation time
– Numerical solver time step

Benefits of Scenario-Based Vehicle Simulation

Cost-Effective Development It reduces the need for physical prototypes and road testing, saving time and resources. Simulations can be run repeatedly with different variables to cover a wide range of scenarios efficiently. Simulating scenarios reduces the need for physical prototypes and extensive road testing, which can be expensive and time-consuming. This allows for more efficient use of resources during the development phase.

Eco-Friendly Development By optimizing vehicle performance through simulations, manufacturers can develop more fuel-efficient and environmentally friendly vehicles. Simulations can also model the environmental impact of different vehicle technologies and driving behaviors.

Risk-Free Testing It offers a safe environment to test vehicle systems and driver responses without the risk of real-world consequences. This is particularly important for testing dangerous or extreme driving conditions.

Iterative Testing Scenario-based simulations enable repetitive and varied testing without additional costs. Engineers can run numerous simulations with different parameters to refine and optimize vehicle systems and designs.

Enhanced Safety and Performance By simulating various scenarios, engineers and developers can identify potential safety issues and optimize vehicle performance. This leads to safer, more reliable vehicles.

System Reliability By testing vehicle systems (e.g., brakes, steering, ADAS) in simulated scenarios, manufacturers can identify and address potential failures or weaknesses, ensuring higher reliability and safety in the final product.

Regulatory Compliance – Meeting Standards & Scenario Coverage
Vehicle manufacturers must ensure their products comply with various safety and performance standards. Simulations can help in pre-certification testing, ensuring that vehicles meet regulatory requirements before undergoing official testing. Simulations allow manufacturers to demonstrate how their vehicles perform across a wide range of regulatory scenarios, providing evidence of compliance with safety and performance standards.

Application Examples

• Automotive Industry: Engineers use simulations to test new vehicle technologies, such as advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), in different driving scenarios. This helps in fine-tuning the systems before real-world deployment.
• Autonomous Vehicles: Simulating complex driving environments helps in training and validating self-navigating algorithms. These simulations include various traffic patterns, pedestrian interactions, and unexpected obstacles.
• Advanced Technologies Researchers use scenario-based simulations to explore and develop new vehicle technologies, such as electric drive-trains, connectivity features, and smart infrastructure interactions.
• Driver Training: For improving driving skills and safety by exposing drivers to different realistic road scenarios.
• Human Factors Research: Simulations can study how human operators interact with vehicle systems and environments.

Scenario-based vehicle simulation is a versatile and powerful tool that supports the development, testing, and validation of vehicles in a controlled, cost-effective, and safe manner. It contributes significantly to advancements in vehicle technology, safety, regulatory compliance, and environmental sustainability.

Search tools for Scenario-Based Verification here.